I crafted an Island Rum Punch from aged rum, bright pineapple, and a single surprising spice, and I dare you to guess the secret ingredient.

Jump to Recipe

I first tasted Caribbean Rum Punch on a hot, restless night and it messed with everything I thought I knew about drinks. The blend of light rum and dark or aged rum gives it a kind of friendly danger, then bright fresh squeezed lime juice snaps you awake, like a secret you weren’t supposed to learn.

Folks call it Island Rum Punch but that name doesn’t do the real thing justice, its more complicated and louder. I keep thinking about how one sip can change the whole mood, and I’m already plotting the next time I can try it again.

Ingredients

Print Recipe (No Advertisments)

Ingredient Quantities

1 cup (240 ml) light rum and 1 cup (240 ml) dark or aged rum

1 1/4 cups (300 ml) fresh squeezed orange juice (about 4 oranges)

3/4 cup (180 ml) fresh squeezed lime juice (about 6 limes, give or take)

1 1/2 cups (360 ml) pineapple juice

1/2 cup (120 ml) grenadine syrup

1/2 cup (120 ml) simple syrup or 1/3 cup demerara syrup, to taste

4 to 6 dashes Angostura bitters

1/4 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg, optional for grating on top

Orange slices, lime wedges and pineapple chunks for garnish

Maraschino cherries, optional

Ice for serving

Club soda or sparkling water to top, optional

How to Make this

Print Recipe (No Advertisments)

1. Juice about 4 oranges and 6 limes so you have roughly 1 1/4 cups (300 ml) orange juice and 3/4 cup (180 ml) lime juice, measure out 1 1/2 cups (360 ml) pineapple juice too, set aside.

2. In a large pitcher combine 1 cup (240 ml) light rum, 1 cup (240 ml) dark or aged rum, the orange, lime and pineapple juices, 1/2 cup (120 ml) grenadine and 1/2 cup (120 ml) simple syrup or 1/3 cup demerara syrup; add 4 to 6 dashes of Angostura bitters.

3. Stir well until everything is mixed and the syrups are dissolved, taste it and adjust sweetness or tartness by adding more syrup or lime juice if needed.

4. If you want it smoother, chill the pitcher for 30 minutes or strain the punch through a fine sieve to remove pulp, otherwise leave the pulp for more body and flavor.

5. Fill individual glasses with ice (large cubes or crushed, crushed dilutes faster but chills quicker), pour the punch leaving a little room at the top if you plan to add soda.

6. Top each glass with a splash of club soda or sparkling water for a little fizz, stir gently so you dont lose all the bubbles.

7. Garnish with orange slices, lime wedges, pineapple chunks and an optional maraschino cherry; grate a tiny pinch of fresh nutmeg on top if you like that warm note.

8. Serve immediately, or store the punch (without soda) in the fridge up to 24 hours, keep soda separate till serving and use big ice cubes to avoid over-dilution.

Equipment Needed

1. Citrus juicer or hand reamer, for the orange and lime juice
2. Measuring cups and spoons, for juices, syrups and rum
3. Large pitcher (2 to 3 quart) or mixing bowl to combine everything
4. Long spoon or bar spoon to stir until the syrups dissolve
5. Fine mesh sieve, if you want to strain out pulp (optional)
6. Cocktail jigger or small measuring cup for accurate rum pours
7. Microplane or small grater for the fresh nutmeg
8. Ice scoop or tongs, cause grabbing ice with hands is gross
9. Highball or Collins glasses for serving, plus a few straws or spoons if you like

FAQ

Can I use bottled juice instead of fresh? Yes you can, but fresh juice tastes brighter and more tropical. If you must use bottled, pick 100 percent juice, avoid sweetened orange, and taste as you go since bottled lime can be sharper so you may want less simple syrup.

Can I make this non alcoholic? Sure, swap the rums for extra pineapple and orange juice plus a splash of coconut water or a non alcoholic rum alternative. Note Angostura bitters contain alcohol so omit them or use an alcohol free bitter. Top with club soda for fizz.

How far ahead can I make the punch? Make the punch base up to 24 hours ahead and keep it chilled, you can stretch to 48 hours but citrus starts to taste off after that. Do not add ice or soda until right before serving so it does not get watery.

Is this recipe very strong and can I adjust it? It is on the boozy side, yes. If you want it lighter, halve the rum or top each glass with club soda. You can also increase the juices slightly to dilute without losing the flavor.

What kind of rums should I use? Use a mix of light rum for a clean backbone and a dark or aged rum for depth and caramel notes. A Demerara or Jamaican style dark rum works great, just avoid flavored rums that fight the citrus and pineapple.

How should I garnish and serve it? Serve over plenty of ice in a punch bowl or individual glasses, add orange slices, lime wedges, pineapple chunks and maraschino cherries. If you like, grate a little fresh nutmeg on top for a warm aroma right before serving.

Caribbean Rum Punch Recipe Substitutions and Variations

Rum (light + dark): swap with 2 cups light rum for a brighter, fruitier punch; or use 2 cups dark/aged rum for deeper molasses notes; or split with spiced rum for warm spice; or go non alcoholic with a rum alternative (Ritual, Lyre’s) or 2 cups strong black tea plus 1 tbsp molasses per cup to mimic body.
Orange juice: use tangerine or blood orange juice for a sweeter, more floral profile; or replace 1/4 cup with mango or passion fruit juice for extra tropical punch; or use high quality store bought 100% orange juice in a pinch, just add a touch more lime if it tastes flat.
Lime juice: swap part or all with key lime juice if you want tarter, more aromatic citrus; or use fresh lemon juice plus a splash of lime cordial if limes are scarce; bottled lime juice works but reduce slightly because it can be sharper.
Grenadine / simple syrup: if you dont have grenadine use pomegranate molasses thinned with a little simple syrup, or raspberry or cherry syrup for similar color and sweetness; for simple syrup use equal parts demerara or brown sugar syrup, or honey syrup (1:1 honey to warm water) or agave to keep it vegan friendly.

Pro Tips

1. Let the batch rest in the fridge at least 30 minutes and up to a few hours so the juices and rums mellow together. Taste and rebalance before serving, add a bit more lime for brightness or a splash of syrup if its too tart.

2. Use large ice cubes or ice balls so the drink chills without getting watered down fast. Another trick is to freeze some of the punch into cubes and use those to keep flavor while avoiding dilution.

3. Grate the nutmeg right before serving and add an extra dash of Angostura to each glass for a fresher aroma; putting all the bitters in the pitcher can flatten them over time. Swap part of the simple syrup for demerara if you want more depth, but go easy so the fruit still shines.

4. If you’re making this for a crowd make the punch up to 24 hours ahead but keep soda separate until serving. Strain through a fine sieve for a silky finish or leave the pulp in if you prefer more texture, just warn guests it wont be perfectly smooth.

Caribbean Rum Punch Recipe

Recipe by Sam Ecclestone

0.0 from 0 votes

I crafted an Island Rum Punch from aged rum, bright pineapple, and a single surprising spice, and I dare you to guess the secret ingredient.

Servings

servings

Calories

245

kcal

Equipment: 1. Citrus juicer or hand reamer, for the orange and lime juice
2. Measuring cups and spoons, for juices, syrups and rum
3. Large pitcher (2 to 3 quart) or mixing bowl to combine everything
4. Long spoon or bar spoon to stir until the syrups dissolve
5. Fine mesh sieve, if you want to strain out pulp (optional)
6. Cocktail jigger or small measuring cup for accurate rum pours
7. Microplane or small grater for the fresh nutmeg
8. Ice scoop or tongs, cause grabbing ice with hands is gross
9. Highball or Collins glasses for serving, plus a few straws or spoons if you like

Ingredients

1 cup (240 ml) light rum and 1 cup (240 ml) dark or aged rum
1 1/4 cups (300 ml) fresh squeezed orange juice (about 4 oranges)
3/4 cup (180 ml) fresh squeezed lime juice (about 6 limes, give or take)
1 1/2 cups (360 ml) pineapple juice
1/2 cup (120 ml) grenadine syrup
1/2 cup (120 ml) simple syrup or 1/3 cup demerara syrup, to taste
4 to 6 dashes Angostura bitters
1/4 teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg, optional for grating on top
Orange slices, lime wedges and pineapple chunks for garnish
Maraschino cherries, optional
Ice for serving
Club soda or sparkling water to top, optional

Directions

Juice about 4 oranges and 6 limes so you have roughly 1 1/4 cups (300 ml) orange juice and 3/4 cup (180 ml) lime juice, measure out 1 1/2 cups (360 ml) pineapple juice too, set aside.
In a large pitcher combine 1 cup (240 ml) light rum, 1 cup (240 ml) dark or aged rum, the orange, lime and pineapple juices, 1/2 cup (120 ml) grenadine and 1/2 cup (120 ml) simple syrup or 1/3 cup demerara syrup; add 4 to 6 dashes of Angostura bitters.
Stir well until everything is mixed and the syrups are dissolved, taste it and adjust sweetness or tartness by adding more syrup or lime juice if needed.
If you want it smoother, chill the pitcher for 30 minutes or strain the punch through a fine sieve to remove pulp, otherwise leave the pulp for more body and flavor.
Fill individual glasses with ice (large cubes or crushed, crushed dilutes faster but chills quicker), pour the punch leaving a little room at the top if you plan to add soda.
Top each glass with a splash of club soda or sparkling water for a little fizz, stir gently so you dont lose all the bubbles.
Garnish with orange slices, lime wedges, pineapple chunks and an optional maraschino cherry; grate a tiny pinch of fresh nutmeg on top if you like that warm note.
Serve immediately, or store the punch (without soda) in the fridge up to 24 hours, keep soda separate till serving and use big ice cubes to avoid over-dilution.

Notes

Below you’ll find my best estimate of this recipe’s nutrition facts. Treat the numbers as a guide rather than a rule—great food should nourish both body and spirit. Figures are approximate, and the website owner assumes no liability for any inaccuracies in this recipe.